Heat Pump Vs Gas Furnace

QUESTION:

Here's an option I'm considering. I talked to my local HVAC company, and they're suggesting I install a heat pump system. (York TriathlonTM Heating and Cooling System ). I have an older natural gas furnace, and the cold air returns need replacing. Would the heat pump be a good option? I live in Michigan and it gets cold. I've heard that heat pumps don't produce heat that feels as warm as natural gas heat. Would the heat pump be a good choice for an older 2000 sq foot two story house?

ANSWER:

I am a York dealer, and I would not use an old Triathlon unit...it had good ideas...none really worked...thats another reason they have not been made in forever..
In your area, IF you go with a heat pump, I would strongly suggest that you get gas as your backup heat option, with a fossil fuel timer added to the unit. Heat pumps do not produce a heat that is warm as a fossil fuel, and thats fine, as even when it got below 0F here in NC for a few days last year, we had no problems maintaining 70F indoors...and thats with a York heat pump..but for your area, gas would be the better option..at least in my opinion.
I suspect that your local company has one left over that they bought, or the supplier they use is making some REALLY good deals to get rid of the old stuff, and thats why hes pushing it...I would suggest that if you are using a York dealer, you ask about a Diamond 90 unit..or a package unit...or anything but the Trialthlon unit...or find another company that will listen to you, your concerns, and not install something that will be a troublsome unit as time goes on.


Submit your comment or answer




Privacy Policy